Why Self-Leadership Is Tough for Young Professionals (and What Employers Can Do About It)

Cathie Leimbach • May 20, 2025

Starting a first job is exciting—but it can also be overwhelming. For many young professionals, self-leadership doesn’t come easily right away, and that’s not a reflection of intelligence or motivation. Instead, it’s the result of a mix of biological, educational, and social factors that employers need to understand.


1. The Brain Is Still Under Construction

Let’s start with biology. The prefrontal cortex, which handles planning, prioritizing, and self-regulation, continues to develop into a person’s mid-twenties. That means young professionals are often still building the mental wiring needed for independent decision-making.


2. School Prepared Them for Structure, Not Ambiguity

Most educational systems are built around standardized testing and structured learning environments. Students are trained to follow clear rubrics and respond to well-defined expectations. But the modern workplace often requires people to operate in gray areas—to take initiative and figure things out without much guidance. That’s a big adjustment for someone fresh out of school.


3. Parenting Styles Play a Role

Many young adults grew up under the watchful eyes of “helicopter” or “snowplow” parents—well-meaning guardians who hovered or cleared obstacles from their paths. While these styles may reduce stress in the short term, they can unintentionally limit the development of autonomous decision-making and risk-taking. The result? Lower self-efficacy and a tendency to hesitate in unfamiliar or challenging situations at work.


4. Technology Has Changed Problem-Solving

We live in an era of instant answers. When a problem comes up, it’s second nature to Google it or ask ChatGPT. While this can be efficient, it also means that many young professionals haven’t had as much practice with internal problem-solving strategies—like critical thinking, trial and error, or strategic patience.


What Employers Can Do

The key takeaway: this is about inexperience, not a lack of potential. With the right approach, employers can help young professionals grow into strong, self-led contributors. Here’s how:

Set crystal-clear expectations from day one

Provide thorough onboarding and training

Start with close supervision, then gradually reduce it as they gain confidence

Offer regular, structured feedback

Encourage self-reflection and ownership

Pair them with mentors who model professional self-leadership


A Helpful Framework: Situational Leadership II®

One tool that’s especially helpful here is Ken Blanchard’s Situational Leadership II® model. It outlines four stages of leadership support—from directing, to coaching, to supporting, to delegating. It’s a great roadmap for helping a new employee grow from needing guidance to performing independently.


The Payoff

With intentional support, most young professionals develop workplace autonomy within 12 to 18 months. They just need time, guidance, and the chance to stretch their wings.


Final Thought:
If you're leading early-career professionals, your role isn't just to manage—they're looking to you to help them grow. Be patient. Be clear. And remember, self-leadership is a skill that develops over time—with the right leader, it can flourish.

How Managers Drive 70% of Performance

By Cathie Leimbach • February 17, 2026
Most CEOs focus on strategy, systems, and talent. But the biggest driver of performance is already in place: managers. Manager behavior influences about 70% of team engagement and results. What happens in everyday conversations matters more than perks, pay, or policies. Managers either multiply energy or drain it. Clear, supportive managers raise performance. Avoiding, inconsistent managers quietly lower it. The good news? Small habits make a big difference: Clarifying expectations Giving timely feedback Addressing issues early Reinforcing priorities These moments add up. Instead of telling managers to “motivate people,” try asking: Where might expectations be unclear? Where is inconsistency allowed? What conversation is being avoided? When managers improve just a little, results improve a lot. 👉 Join our 60-minute Leadership Conversation to explore how everyday manager habits quietly shape engagement and results.

Why Engagement Isn’t About Perks

By Cathie Leimbach • February 10, 2026
When engagement drops, many organizations reach for perks—rewards, programs, or incentives. These can create a short lift, but they rarely solve the real issue. Engagement starts with expectations. Most people want to do good work. What gets in the way isn’t motivation—it’s uncertainty. When priorities shift, roles feel unclear, or success means different things to different leaders, people disengage quietly. Leaders often don’t realize they’re contributing to this. Vague direction, inconsistent follow-through, or assuming “they already know” leaves teams guessing. Over time, guessing turns into frustration—and frustration turns into disengagement. Strong engagement cultures focus on leadership basics: Clear priorities Shared definitions of success Aligned expectations Consistent reinforcement When expectations are clear, people move with confidence. They take ownership, collaborate better, and stay engaged because they know where they’re headed. Perks can support engagement—but only after clarity is in place. 👉 Read our full article on Why Engagement Starts With Expectations to turn clarity into a real advantage.