Speaking Up Is Not Defiance. It's Duty.

Cathie Leimbach • June 23, 2026

Most leaders say they want employees to speak up.  


They want people who spot risks, question assumptions, and help the organization make better decisions. 

 

Yet many employees hesitate to do exactly that.  


Why?  


Because leaders often respond to speaking up as if the speaker is complaining, criticizing or resisting.  


When people fear being viewed as difficult, they stop sharing what they see. The organization loses valuable information, ideas, and perspectives.  


A recent McKinsey article found that teams with high psychological safety are two to three times more likely to generate breakthrough ideas. When people feel safe speaking up, better thinking follows.  


The best leaders understand a simple truth:  


Speaking up is not defiance. It's duty.  


When employees question assumptions, raise concerns, or offer a different perspective, they are helping the team avoid blind spots and make stronger decisions.  


That's why effective leaders don't merely tolerate speaking up—they invite it.  


They ask:  

  • What are we not seeing?  
  • What assumptions are we making?  
  • Who might see this differently?  
  • What information are we missing?  


Just as importantly, they respond with curiosity instead of defensiveness.  


They thank people for expressing their perspective.  


They explain how input influenced decisions.  


They make speaking up safe.  


Because organizations don't improve when everyone agrees.  


They improve when people feel responsible for helping the team see what others may have missed.  


In healthy organizations, speaking up isn't rebellion.  


It's responsibility.  


It's duty.  


Leadership Reflection  


Think about your last leadership team meeting.  


Did people simply agree?  


Or did someone help the team see something it otherwise would have missed?  


Download 5 Questions That Surface Better Thinking and make speaking up a productive part of how your team thinks, decides, and performs. 

By Cathie Leimbach August 4, 2026
Most employees know what they are expected to do each day. Far fewer fully understand why their work matters or how it contributes to the organization's success. Yet that understanding is one of the most powerful drivers of engagement, commitment, and performance. Gallup research consistently shows that employees who feel connected to their organization's mission and purpose are significantly more engaged, while highly engaged teams achieve stronger productivity, profitability, customer satisfaction, and retention. When people understand how their individual responsibilities help customers, coworkers, and the organization succeed, their work becomes more than a list of tasks—it has meaning. Supervisors play the key role in creating that understanding. A job description explains what to do. Leadership conversations explain why it matters. They help employees see how quality, safety, customer service, teamwork, and continuous improvement all connect to the organization's goals. As work changes, priorities shift, or new challenges arise, supervisors who communicate openly help employees understand not only what is changing, but why those changes matter. Questions, discussion, and regular feedback replace assumptions with clarity and build trust. Employees who understand the purpose behind their work are more likely to make good decisions, solve problems, take initiative, and remain committed during difficult times. They also appreciate knowing that their organization is willing to invest in their future through learning and career development opportunities, even if promotion is not immediate. When supervisors consistently connect daily work to a larger purpose through meaningful conversations, employees gain direction, confidence, and motivation. They don't simply complete tasks—they understand the difference they make. And that understanding creates a workplace where engagement, performance, and retention naturally grow. Need Help with a Difficult Workplace Conversation? Great leadership doesn't happen by accident—it happens one conversation at a time. You Don't Need to Go It Alone. Bring your workplace people challenges to the FREE Workplace Conversations Clinic on August 17. Gain insights from Cathie Leimbach and other attendees as you explore practical ways to handle the situations you're facing. Register here for the FREE Workplace Conversations Clinic Conversation is where leadership happens.
By Cathie Leimbach July 28, 2026
From uncertainty to confident, supportive leadership conversations